Peer review prior to publication

#1

There was just a posting on the OTN list asking about pre-publication peer review options for open textbook authors. I’m hoping that this platform, through it’s list of experts, can provide a solution to this question.

(Hugh McGuire) #2

Hi Marilyn,

Indeed peer-review is a big part of what I think needs to be worked out for Open Textbooks. So we do hope that, along with OTN and others, we can help make that easier.

I think at the least, there ought to be a listing of projects (books? chapters?), with information about them, in need of reviewing.

Then we get into questions such as:

  • should the review process be open? ie can anyone review? invite only? how is that managed?
  • are there different levels of review? eg, one round of “closed” reviews, then an open pre-pub public review? etc…

But in any case, yes this is a critical part of the infrastructure we hope to help with.

(Steel Wagstaff) #3

I think that this something that the Open Textbook Network might be ideally suited to help facilitate? They’ve already got a good infrastructure in place for post-publication faculty review and a large network of trained faculty reviewers at several institutions … What do you think, @dernst?

1 Like